Cinderella Mom
Share
by Molly Schroeder
In my daughter's first four years of life, I approached parenting with a feeling like Cinderella on her hands and knees scrubbing soot whilst my evil stepmother loomed over me, judging and chastising my every move. Nothing I did was good enough. It took me years of this misery (and plenty of therapy) to finally recognize that the nasty stepmother was me and the unreasonable requests she was making all stemmed from my own beliefs and assumptions about motherhood.
Nowhere did this ridiculous expectation of mothering standards become more clear than at my daughter’s birthday party.
The Dreaded Birthday Party Gift Bag Debacle
We had just moved into our forever home and were anxious to open our doors to guests. What better chance than a birthday party? I have never been an organized or structured person (thanks, ADHD), follow-through is not my strong suit. My most successful parties up until this stage in life had always involved impromptu hang-outs after the bar closed, replete with mixed drinks and loud music. Frilly unicorn invitations, pink-frosted cupcakes, healthy alternative snacks, structured party games? Out of my wheelhouse. But that is what a good mom does, so I gritted my teeth and set to planning a day to forge a memory to last a lifetime. Someday, when accepting her Oscar or Nobel, she would acknowledge my love and dedication. So I needed streamers for that.

The party was one of the most miserable experiences of my life. I quickly realized that no amount of structured and intentionally planned activities could keep the attention of a gaggle of littles longer than a few minutes. They were better suited tearing around my house, ripping plaster from the walls, and losing M&Ms under my couch. The sound of their joyful shrieks might bring a smile to the face of many mothers, a reassurance of fun, but to me, every shrill note sent my shoulders toward my ears as I imagined scrubbing footprints from the ceiling.
Wait. I Was Supposed to Make Goodie Bags?
After what felt like my sixteen-hour labor, parents began to shove tiny feet into tiny boots, the pile of jackets by the door began to dwindle. I stood like a sentinel, ready to usher them outside when a mother quietly whispered into her child’s ear and she came bounding up to me, face eager as she asked, “Where’s my treat?”
“Treat?” I repeated, genuinely dumbfounded. Treat? Like another cupcake? Cookies, candy? Surely this little monster had eaten enough sugar. But happy to be rid of leftovers, I replied, “Grab another cupcake, Sweetie.”
She stood staring blankly at me. I looked around, desperate for her parental unit to take over this awkward exchange. Her mother intervened and said, “She means treat BAGS. You know, goodie bags? For the guests?”
Horror.
Followed by awareness and then blinding embarrassment. The familiar voice of the evil stepmother shamed my ignorance. How could I be so stupid? It wasn’t a concept that had even crossed my mind. As a kid in the 80s, the idea of buying gifts for the guests of the party didn’t exist. Our parties were free-for-alls, where parents either dumped you from a moving vehicle so they could get a moment's reprieve or they stood in the backyard drinking and smoking while we jumped from the roof or wandered into the woods unsupervised. Sure, it was a different time and there are a whole host of issues that created, but I bet my mom never experienced the guilt I was feeling.

Stunned and wishing everyone would simply GTFO, I scrambled and panic-packed old toys, broken crayons, and loose candies into sandwich baggies. Parents looked at me quizzically as I shoved miscellaneous garbage into the outstretched paws of their expectant children and I slammed the door after the last departure, vowing to never host another party for as long as I live.
That Isn’t Me: Letting Go of Mom Guilt
I spent days reeling from my oversight, judging myself harshly, berating my ignorance. Finally landing on a solitary thought: That isn't ME.
Goodie bags aren’t objectively good or bad; they’re just sacks filled with stuff (IMHO, stuff that will likely end up in a landfill). I allowed goodie bags to be one more place where I was comparing my ability to be a good parent. Some moms love putting these treats together, meticulously selecting perfect items and tying flawless bows, while I am much more comfortable tossing burgers on a grill and blasting 90s hip-hop with a beverage in hand. Neither is right or wrong. Neither activity tells us which one is a good mom or a bad mom. The problem was never that my version of Cinderella didn’t scrub the sooty floor well enough; it was whether I had ever stopped to ask why I was scrubbing it in the first place.
My daughter had a great birthday, she never knew of my faux pas, she made friends. No one sent me harshly worded emails about the reckless endangerment of their children’s well-being due to my lack of goodie bags (they can do that behind my back like civilized people). The only judgment came from my own evil stepmother, measuring my motherhood against what I thought other moms were doing.

Redefining Motherhood on My Own Terms
I learned that I am not happy being a hostess. I am not happy doing Cinderella tasks simply because I think I’m supposed to. I am happiest when I am not holding myself to a standard I didn’t create. Now, instead of suffering, I ask myself the following:
- Which parts of motherhood actually feel like me?
- Which things am I doing because I genuinely want to—and which because I think good mothers are supposed to?
- When I feel judged by other mothers, is anyone actually judging me—or has my own evil stepmother shown up again?
Molly Schroeder is a therapist, writer, and mother in the Pacific Northwest. Her writing explores the messy intersection of motherhood, relationships, identity, and our often ridiculous attempts to get life right. She believes humor belongs in conversations about serious things and is endlessly curious about why we do the things we do. https://wanderingpaththerapy.